DiPerna's Lawyer: My Client is Innocent

The cases for the three suspects charged in the Roxen Road assault case were recently adjourned to August and September.

The three Rockville Centre teens who allegedly on Roxen Road in June recently appeared in Nassau County District Court, and their cases were adjourned until a later date, according to District Court officials.

, both 18, will be back in court on Aug. 14, while , 18, will appear on Sept. 25.

John R. Lewis, Jr., the attorney for Matt DiPerna, recently spoke with Patch to  give his client's side of the story.

"I believe these boys will be vindicated at the end of the day," Lewis said. "The real question is, this is an accusation. We don't punish people or run families out of town based on accusations."

Lewis was responding to left on an RVC Patch article thread, where anonymous posters suggested punishments for the alleged attackers and their families.

"It is my contention that the alleged victim was not looking for an apology, but started the physical altercation," he said.


Interested in Rockville Centre news, events, community bulletins, blogs and businesses? Sign up for the free Rockville Centre Patch daily newsletter and follow us on Facebook!


Lewis said that on June 18, there was a group of 10-15 kids on a street near a friend's house. Lewis said he's not denying that the boys were boisterous or said off-colored remarks to the wife of the husband, but explained that the rest of the story and how it was portrayed in the media was "fantasy."

He said the boys split up into several groups, and when the wife and husband found one of the groups on Roxen Road, she pointed out one teen, who Lewis said was not DiPerna.

"He (the husband) proceeded to exact vengeance for what he perceived as a slight on his wife," Lewis said. "He hit one of the boys. He was the aggressor."

Lewis added that witnesses only saw the tail end of the altercation, and from what his research shows, his client's side of the story is the truth.

"Our contention is that he (the husband) was a vigilante," he said. "He started the confrontation and wouldn't let it die."

According to the Rockville Centre Police Department, who issued a through the village spokesperson on the case, the husband was attacked first after asking the boys for an apology. The name of the 43-year-old resident involved in the attack was not released.

Lewis noted that the issue has polarized the community and made it difficult to deal with, especially when some are convicting the three boys before they have their day in court.

"There is a judicial process, and they are innocent until proven guilty," he said.

The lawyers for William Moore and Kevin Coyle did not return several messages left by RVC Patch.

Lawyer with a conscience August 07, 2012 at 01:23 PM
The kids were out on the street. Apparently no "house" was involved---but who sold them the stuff?
Joe Griffin August 07, 2012 at 03:29 PM
Regardless of what is said in this forum, no one knows all the facts surrounding this case and the court will ultimately decide the fate of these teeangers. It's obviously not surprising that the defense "contends" that his client is innocent. Not sure how NY jurisdiction views these types of claims but similar cases in the U.S. outside of New York have resulted in victims hiring personal injury lawyers during criminal proceedings and filing civil suits against both assailants and their parents for allegations including assault and battery, parental liability, negligence, infliction of emotional distress. The plaintiffs are also exposed to the wife separately filing emotional distressm, loss of consortium claims, etc. While financial award for criminal actions is not the answer I have a feeling this might be the beginning of a very long road for all parties involved....
joe thrapp August 07, 2012 at 03:48 PM
JG, I get it, good defense theory! Drunk 44 year old man goes hunting for vengeance. He tracks down the 8 alleged drunken 18 year old's and launches an attack. He becomes the attacker and the 8 men become the defenders and they allegedly, summarily beat the man unconscious not once but twice. The 8 men go to the police and report the incident because their parents tell them that's the right thing to do because it was self defense. JG it reads like a fictional account from a Law and Order episode. I for one have not rushed to judgement on any of the participants. I look forward to the trial and hear how this incident began and actually ended.
SSHS87_MENCH August 10, 2012 at 07:23 PM
O.J. Simpson was Innocent too.
Mr. RVC October 16, 2012 at 05:05 PM
If these kids were from Old Mill ct. there would be no way in hell the patch would post an article saying that they are innocent. LOL.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »